John Foreman
“It's an Owensboro dish, you don't get it outside of Owensboro, it's what we're known for, kind of our specialty.”
John Foreman comes from five generations of barbecue cooks in Owensboro, Kentucky. In 2014 he owned Old Hickory, the family restaurant on Washington Avenue. His great-great-grandfather, Charles "Pappy" Foreman, began cooking on the side in 1918 while he worked as a blacksmith. John started working for his dad before he was a teenager. A 2013 report put his start in the family business at age ten. He once planned to become a lawyer. In 2012 producers of BBQ Pitmasters on Destination America invited him to an episode. He did not own a pit, so he bought one only weeks before the contest. The cook-off ran at the Big Buffalo Crossing Cook-Off in Munfordville, Kentucky, and gave each cook 12 hours. His rivals were Roy Henry and Mike Ramage. Aaron Franklin, Tuffy Stone, and Myron Mixon judged. Foreman won the title of Pitmaster Kentucky Champion and a $2,000 prize. The mystery meats were fresh ham and mutton. He said he cooked the mutton the way Old Hickory does. He felt his father deserved the recognition more than he did.
Technique
Old Hickory smokes its barbecue, including mutton, over hickory and uses the same sauce and dip recipes the family has passed down for generations.